Minimize

Welcome!

IMF to Delay decision on yuan

August 6, 2015

This is an interesting article send to us by our friend Peter Brandt. It is an interesting update on what is happening with the IMF and its decision on whether to include the Yuan in its SDR basket.

Click here to visit the Straits Times website.

IMF staff seek to put off move to add yuan to IMF’s benchmark currency basket until after September 2016

The International Monetary Fund should put off any move to add the yuan to its benchmark currency basket until after September 2016, IMF staff said in a report which showed a mixed performance of the yuan on meeting key financial norms.

The report, published on Tuesday, comes after Beijing launched a major diplomatic push for the yuan to be added to the IMF’s Special Drawing Rights basket as part of its long-term strategic goal of reducing dependence on the dollar.

The IMF board is scheduled to make a decision in November on whether to include the yuan in a basket of currencies comprising dollars, euros, pounds and yen, although the decision could be pushed back if policymakers decide they need more information.

Delaying any change for nine months through September 2016 would avoid disrupting financial market trading on the first day of the new year, the report said. A senior IMF official said reserve asset managers would need about six months notice to adjust to a change.

The yuan meets the requirements as a significant currency in terms of international trade, but also has to be judged to be “freely usable”.

The delay would also mean China will keep the yuan pegged to the US dollar into 2016, analysts said. It is around 6.2 a US dollar since March.

“It is possible that China may continue to hold the yuan stable into next year given the push out of likely SDR entry date,” Nomura Holdings Inc strategists Craig Chan and Wee Choon Teo wrote in a note.

The de-facto peg to the US dollar has made the yuan the best performer in emerging markets over the past three months, helping stem capital outflows as Chinese policymakers seek to arrest a US$4 trillion (S$5.5 trillion) stocks rout. Inclusion in the IMF’s SDRs would attract as much as US$1 trillion from abroad into China’s bond market over five years, Standard Chartered estimated in May.

The report said the yuan meets the requirements as a significant currency in terms of international trade, but also has to be judged to be “freely usable”, or widely used to make international payments and readily traded on foreign exchange markets. It shows a mixed performance on financial criteria. Although the currency is increasingly used in cross-border transactions and heavily traded in Asia, it is only thinly traded in North America and is not commonly used in international debt securities.

Data was missing for some variables, the report said.

The senior IMF official said there was no set checklist of indicators to guide the decision and no “off-on” switch on whether the yuan would make the grade at the planned review. But he said politics would play no role in the decision which will govern the mix of currencies that countries like Greece receive as part of disbursements from the IMF.

“They should be able to use it directly or they should be able to sell it immediately,” the official said.

Analysts interpreted the IMF delay differently, with some inferring the IMF wanted to see a more freely traded yuan before including it as a reserve currency.

Others said the delay seemed technical, aimed at giving the market more time to prepare. “The IMF article implies a large likelihood of SDR inclusion – otherwise the technical preparation would not be necessary,” UBS economist Wang Tao said in a note to clients.

IMF managing director Christine Lagarde has said adding the yuan to the basket is a “question of when”.

European members of the Group of Seven major industrialised economies – Germany, Britain, France and Italy – favour adding the yuan to the basket quickly. Japan, like the United States, is more cautious, officials have said.

Discussion
22 Comments
    Aug 06, 2015 06:35 AM

    The Yuan can’t be part of an SDR basket until they de-peg from the $U.S., and then live with the consequences of massive currency appreciation. Something similar what happened to the South African Rand forward since 2002. Or you might bet on Mexican Peso appreciation, since manufacturing has moved there, too.

      Aug 06, 2015 06:42 AM

      It is said that US and Japan are against the inclusion and the rest all support the inclusion of Yuan in IMF. It is a veto. Politics is more important than anything. US cannot see Yuan become the reserve currency and Japan just want to hurt China by helping US.

        Aug 06, 2015 06:00 AM

        It is ridiculous to exclude the second largest economy and the largest manufacturing economy from the currency basket. If IMF keeps doing it, it will become irrelevant in the future just like G7.

          Aug 06, 2015 06:05 AM

          Pegging to the world reserve currency is a common practice and considered to be good practice. None of other countries were even slightly criticized, such as Hongkong, Swiss, etc. Before 1971, everyone did it.

            Aug 06, 2015 06:12 AM

            De-peg first, then we’ll talk.

            Aug 06, 2015 06:31 AM

            Sound like a black mail. They did it for WTO. China made many concessions but they eventually hurt the west even it added hardship on China at beginning.

            Aug 06, 2015 06:54 AM

            A fully pegged currency to the $U.S. will eventually cause such an imbalance that China will begin to look like Greece, which can’t get out from under their Euro obligations.

            Aug 06, 2015 06:37 AM

            The relative size of China to US is different than Greece to Europe. China is already larger than US in manufacturing and #1 in world trade. China has huge trade surplus and Greece has a trade deficit. The comparison is when satellite rotates around planet, the satellite has to be a lot smaller. China only peg to USD when it benefits China. It will not be permanent. It used to be 8.2:1 and now 6.2:1. Maybe one day USD will try to peg to Yuan. 🙂

            Aug 06, 2015 06:07 PM

            Wishful thinking, since foreign capital is fleeing China.

            Aug 06, 2015 06:23 PM

            Nothing to do with wishes. It is the life span of old and new power.

    Aug 06, 2015 06:37 AM

    “Maybe when China gets around to updating their gold reserves again…perhaps as soon as later this month…they’ll divulge something a little closer to the truth? Maybe, too, they’ll simply turn the tables on the IMF and tell them to go pound sand, instead? We’ll see. All I know is that a lot of supposedly smart people with “insider level” information were convinced that China was only accumulating gold in order to attain this SDR inclusion. With SDR inclusion now looking to be postponed for at least another year, what happens next is anyone’s guess ”

    http://www.tfmetalsreport.com/blog/7041/imf-report-no-sdr-inclusion-chinese-yuan

    Aug 06, 2015 06:03 AM

    IMF……….game playing from the WEST.

      Aug 06, 2015 06:06 AM

      I am thinking …………..PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION 2016 will be in play at the same time.

    Aug 06, 2015 06:10 AM

    I was thinking that I read ………that the decision only comes EVERY 5 YRS…., so if , china did not get in the basket this year…..Why, are they deciding to THINK about it for 2016?

    CFS
    Aug 06, 2015 06:37 AM

    I assume this comment is from Peter L. Brandt, not Peter M. Brandt who is a billionaire and friend of the Donald!
    I wonder if their relative net worths say something about their knowledge?

    CFS
    Aug 06, 2015 06:19 AM
      Aug 06, 2015 06:47 AM

      another date………NOVEMBER….plans are always changing, maybe , because some of the FACTS are out in the open now.

        Aug 06, 2015 06:49 AM

        NOVEMBER 2015 OR SEPT. 2016?………..who is on first , who is on second……

    Aug 07, 2015 07:50 AM

    I got to see [on youtube] Both repub debates .most of the participants were lousy. Carly fiorina was excelent. She was well spoken , and could handle controversy. Bush was too pasive and fumbled a bit with his answers . ron paul, rubio, cruz, and trump did well. the baby debate was also fun to watch , and like i say , carly was stand out and will surly be on stage as a top ten in the polls in the september debate . I also predict that Lincoln Chafe will start to rise in Democrat polls . hillary is in trouble, Sanders is red hot right now , but i think Dems will search for an alterntive to her as bernie is a bit to old . If Biden gets in he will go nowhere as his politics are to much like hillarys . I got skunked on my recent repurchase of DIS but its only temporary . love to all S