Pundit's Perspectives – Thu 21 Apr, 2016

RBC sees parallels between the 1970s and now

In a  recent report published by RBC the bank is making some comparisons between now and the 1970s. In the 70s the Fed did not raise rates in the face of increasing inflation because of global macro issues. This caused the gold price to move up significantly. Read below to find out what other factors RBC is looking at to support this call.

This article was originally posted to the Value Walk website – click here to visit the site.

RBC: Gold Price Set To Push Higher As Inflation Picks Up

Analysis suggests a -0.5% real rate would imply a $1,380/oz gold price and a -1.0% real rate $1,546/oz” — that’s according to RBC’s April 10 Global Gold Outlook note, which takes a look at how lower real interest rates, coupled with a dovish Fed will impact the gold price.

Consumer prices in the United States rose 0.9% year-on-year in March of 2016, indicating that inflation is reemerging after a long period of dormancy. This should have sparked a more hawkish tone from Federal Reserve policymakers. However, the recent significant global volatility in January and February has left the path for rate hikes in 2016 much more uncertain and led to a sudden dovish turn by the FOMC.

And with inflation picking up, but the Fed unable to hike because of global macro issues, RBC speculates that there are now growing parallels to the 1970s when external pressures and fragile growth rates did not allow the Fed to hike. This was also notably a time of strong gold price appreciation.

Gold price: Repeating history 

As US monetary policy remains accommodative and inflation ticks higher, the potential for lower real interest rates is increasing. The last time such an anomaly was seen in the markets was back in the 1970s. During this period, inflation and inflation expectations shot higher although there was little that could be done to cool inflation from a monetary policy perspective as any rate height would have likely led to a serious recession. Spiking inflation and stagnant interest rates caused real interest rates to fall below the neutral 2% level and even moved sharply negative for a short period. Gold rose from $125/oz in 1976 to a peak of $800/oz in 1980.

In a normal environment, when inflation expectations are positive, but contained or falling, real interest rates have tended to be positive. In an environment such as this, the cost of owning gold is equal to this real interest rate or what is being given up vs. other yielding assets after inflation. When real interest rates are negative the cost of owning gold declines, driving higher demand for the yellow metal, leading to higher prices. RBC’s data shows:

“Since 2008, the correlation between gold and real interest rates (using 10 yr US bond yields and 5yr5yr inflation swaps as a proxy for medium-term inflation) has been high. The R-squared is 60%, with higher correlations in periods of rapid movements in real rates. This high correlation makes logical sense in a period of lower interest rates as well as lower inflation expectations. In 2012-2013, the expectations that monetary policy was on the cusp of normalising (or at least normalising over the longer-term) saw a sharp recovery in real interest rates and a declining gold price. This coincided with the sharp selloff of gold ETFs in 2013.”

gold price inflation 1

Based on historic trends, prices and fundamentals RBC uses a regression analysis, which looks at the relationship between a dependent variable and one or more independent variables, to compute that a negative 0.5% real rate level would suggest a gold price of $1,380/oz and a negative 1.0% real rate level would suggest a gold price $1,546/oz.

What’s more, if market forces continue to hold down US Treasury yields in the face of rising inflation, this could create a 1970s-esque phase in real rates in the short-term. The data suggests that such an environment would lead to higher gold prices although it remains to be seen if prices can repeat their record-breaking 1976 to 1980 run higher.

gold price inflation 2

  1. On April 21, 2016 at 9:55 am,
    CFS says:

    It will be inflation that causes problems for the bond market.

    • On April 21, 2016 at 11:23 am,
      FranSix says:

      I think overall high inflation expectations will continue, though interest rates remain historically low.

  2. On April 21, 2016 at 10:06 am,
    CFS says:

    Interesting that gold and silver were both hit in the futures market today, but platinum and palladium were not touched.
    That is different.

  3. On April 21, 2016 at 11:02 am,
    CFS says:

    Of course, someone’s reading this blog!
    Pt and Pd now being stomped on.

    • On April 21, 2016 at 11:29 am,
      Birdman says:

      Of course.

  4. On April 21, 2016 at 11:26 am,
    FranSix says:

    The TNX/PRII indicator has declined ahead of gold prices, and appears a layup for the crossover of the 13-week EMA with the 89-week EMA. What that suggests is a higher volatility event is meant to occur in the gold space. But this indicator is really stretched, since interest rates are already low.