Minimize

Welcome!

“America’s indispensable friends” Some positive thoughts on U.S. foreign policy contributed by KER’s “educational secretary” Tim Howe

Big Al
November 18, 2017

COMMENTARY

America’s indispensable friends

BY VICTOR DAVIS HANSON

The world equates American military power with the maintenance of the postwar global order of free commerce, communications and travel.

Sometimes American power leads to costly, indecisive interventions like those in Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya that were not able to translate superiority on the battlefield into lasting peace.

But amid the frustrations of American foreign policy, it is forgotten that the United States also plays a critical but more silent role in ensuring the survival of small, at-risk nations. The majority of them are democratic and pro-Western. But they all share the misfortune of living in dangerous neighborhoods full of bullies.

These small nations are a far cry from rogue clients of China and Russia — theocratic Iran, autocratic North Korea and totalitarian Venezuela — that oppress their own people and threaten their regions.

In the Middle East, there are two places that consistently remain pro-American: the nation of Israel and the autonomous region of Iraqi Kurdistan. Both show a spirit and tenacity that so far have ensured their survival against aggressive and far larger neighbors. Both have few friends other than the United States. And both are anomalies. Israel is surrounded by Islamic neighbors. The ethnic Kurds live in the heart of the Arab Middle East. Quite admirably, the U.S. continues to be a patron of both.

For some 500 years, the Ottoman Empire terrified the Christian Middle East and Mediterranean world. Almost every country in its swath was Islamicized. Two tiny unique places were conquered but not transformed: Armenia and Greece. Both suffered terribly at the hands of the Ottomans and their successors, the early-20th-century Turkish state.

Yet both Armenia and Greece remained Christian and kept their languages and cultures. Today, both are still quite vulnerable to renewed neo-Ottoman Turkish pressures.

America has been a friend to both Armenia and Greece, although their histories with the U.S. were often controversial. In turn, they have sent millions of talented and skilled immigrants to the U.S. The world is a far better place because there are 11 million Greeks who keep the legacy of Hellenism alive. Armenia still remains a Western outpost – the first country to formally adopt Christianity as a state religion, and a nation that has preserved its faith under centuries of cruel foreign persecutions.

Without the United States, there would never have emerged a free and independent Taiwan and South Korea. The former would have been absorbed by communist China in 1949. The latter would have been wiped out in 1950 by Chinese-sponsored North Korea. Today, Taiwan and South Korea are models of international citizenship, democracy and prosperity.

Given their relatively small areas, Taiwan and South Korea likely would not have survived Chinese bullying or, more recently, North Korean nuclear provocations without strong American support and protection.

Our relationships with all of these vulnerable nations are as much practical as principled. All follow international law. All have sent gifted citizens to the U.S. All are fiercely self-reliant and are reputed to be among the world’s best fighters.

In the Middle East, age-old enemies are on the move. There is the scourge of radical Islamic terrorism, the specter of a nuclear Iran, and a newly aggressive Turkey.

Kurdistan is threatened variously by Iraq, Iran and Turkey. Iran periodically boasts that it will soon destroy Israel. Iran’s clients in Lebanon and Syria brag that they can launch thousands of missiles into the Jewish state.

Greece is bankrupt and overrun by hundreds of thousands of immigrants, most of them young, male and Muslim. Turkey systematically violates Greek national waters and airspace.

South Korea and Taiwan are both threatened by North Korea’s nuclear-tipped missiles. China periodically warns them that they need to make the necessary subservient adjustments in their foreign policy to accommodate a rising China and a supposedly declining America.

America itself is $20 trillion in debt and divided. It has lost global credibility after years of issuing phony red lines and deadlines to various rivals and enemies.

The U.S. military is in sore need of repair and expansion. Much of the country is sick and tired of costly interventions that could not turn battlefield success into stability, much less into lasting strategic advantage.

Yet a country is not just defined by its economic and military strength, its global clout or its powerful allies. It is also judged on how it treats weaker but humane nations. As long as the U.S. remains good to these impressive but vulnerable states, it will remain great as well.

Email Hanson at author@victorhanson.com.

Discussion
30 Comments
    Nov 18, 2017 18:40 PM

    America has been a friend…

    Translated that’s Uncle Sugar has been ripping off the Ameroconned tax slave for foreign gooberments and other special interests.

    Let’s be real. Nations don’t have friends but politicians do have their cronies…

      Nov 18, 2017 18:07 PM

      I thought that the comments concerning Kurdistan and Israel were pretty interesting, Eddy!

        Nov 19, 2017 19:04 AM

        Al:

        He lives in some strange alternative universe. Israel owns and operates the US for their own benefit. Israel and the US are the most aggressive and belligerent countries on earth.

          Nov 19, 2017 19:56 AM

          Bob, help me out here. Who lives in some strange alternative universe. Thanks

    Nov 18, 2017 18:42 PM

    America itself is $20 trillion in debt and divided. It has lost global credibility after years of issuing phony red lines and deadlines to various rivals and enemies.

    The U.S. military is in sore need of repair and expansion.

    So Uncle Sugar is past broke ($20 trillion plus hundreds of trillions in unfunded liabilities) and spends more on “defense” than any country in the world yet we are in sore need of expanding the military. That’s beyond ridiculous.

      Nov 18, 2017 18:44 PM

      Especially when you consider that our gooberment has foreign bases all over the world, far more than any other country.

      Nov 19, 2017 19:07 AM

      Ebolan:

      Wrong. The US spends more than the next 14 countries in the world combined on our military. It’s only in need of repair because Clinton, Bush, Obama and Trump broke it fighting wars for Israel. Now we are saying we are keeping troops in Syria permanently. How does that work? They had a free election and picked their own leader. How do we get off invading a sovereign nation?

      Oh, I forgot. Israel hates them.

        Nov 19, 2017 19:54 AM

        I just spent about 1/2 hour reminding myself of the situation in Syria. “Let’s leave the Middle East to the Middle East”!

    Nov 18, 2017 18:48 PM

    The world equates American military power with the maintenance of the postwar global order of free commerce, communications and travel.

    May come as a shock but I doubt the “collateral damage” sees it that way. Like these people

    http://www.newsweek.com/wedding-became-funeral-us-still-silent-one-year-deadly-yemen-drone-strike-291403

    Or the victims of US funded ISIS.

    Nov 18, 2017 18:53 PM

    Speaking of America’s enemies…

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=at56A5eg3vs

    Nov 18, 2017 18:57 PM

    This is like an arsonist sponsoring a fire prevention center. Creepy Uncle Joe and Lewdy Googaa!

    Joe Biden And Lady GagaReteam To Establish Sexual Assault Trauma Centres
    http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/joe-biden-lady-gaga-sexual-assault-trauma-centres-its-on-us-organisation-donate-a8055901.html

    Nov 19, 2017 19:01 AM

    Plot to Destroy Trump Hatched in Obama White House – Edward Klein

    Best-selling author Edward Klein’s latest best-selling book is called “All Out War: The Plot to Destroy Trump.” Klein reveals that this plot started in the Obama White House just weeks after Donald Trump won the 2016 election. Klein explains, “Susan Rice was invited to come to a dinner party and give the President (Obama) a plan, and her plan was to unmask the names of Donald Trump associates…

    https://usawatchdog.com/plot-to-destroy-trump-hatched-in-obama-white-house-edward-klein/

      Nov 19, 2017 19:27 AM

      Markedtofuture, I just watched the interview after reading the short article that accompanied it. I have to be honest here in that I am somewhat confused right now between the b.s. and the truth.

      I am not confused in that it is obvious that the Democrats, lead by the Clinton’s have not given up. My confusion stems from Trump’s actions. I think that he is playing into the hands of his domestic enemies with his actions.

      Right now I am personally disappointed in both parties immensely. I have to say that in my opinion the Democrats and the Clinton Family have absolutely no class as they care only about their personal ambitions and not the good of the country. I am disappointed by the actions of Trump in that he could turn this thing around quickly if he adopted the theory that “you can attract more bees with honey than with anything else.” Neither Clinton nor Trump is showing me anything that I would hope to see in a leader.

    GH
    Nov 19, 2017 19:05 PM

    Sorry Al, this article is pretty much just nonsense. Let’s be real about the role the US has played in the world post-WW2–that of global empire. Of course we will have allies and client states that benefit. That doesn’t make it a good system.

    If these aren’t part of your mental landscape, you’re dealing with a very incomplete view of the reality of American foreign policy.

    https://williamblum.org/books/killing-hope#toc

      GH
      Nov 19, 2017 19:06 PM

      Instances of Use of United States Armed Forces Abroad, 1798-2010, Congressional Research Service

      https://fas.org/sgp//crs/natsec/R41677.pdf

      GH
      Nov 19, 2017 19:10 PM

      People seem to think that using the ‘power of positive thinking’ to put a smiley face on American aggression is somehow patriotic or beneficial, when in fact it is the farthest thing from it.

      The worst threat to any people comes from the scoundrels within; empowering them to engage in global conquest also empowers them to be oppressive at home.